Here we have Supergirl in-hand. Near as I can tell, this is either a wholly new sculpt or uses one of the prior Supergirls as a basis (either the Gold Label version from Target or the Page Punchers one based on the awful Woman of Tomorrow story). Accurate to this costume is the navy blue and blood red that honestly makes her appear somewhat regal, and that also goes for the blue background in the chest emblem unlike the usual yellow found. I honestly prefer the gold trim around the logo rather than the yellow some media are using nowadays since it technically makes use of the yellow-like color without a redundant border that doesn't look as nice as a black border on some merch. The proportions seem accurate to the actress's build, though some may say she should have a bit more muscle. As for the cape, it's much thinner in width than the usual Superman cape dimensions, but it is accurate to the way it appeared in the series, and, more importantly, it's wired!
The likeness to actress Melissa Benoist is a pretty good one, even if she looks like she's brainwashed or something with that slightly uncanny smile. It looks better than the smile Christopher Reeve Superman head, but it does look slightly weird for the mouth region. Articulation is the same as usual, though I'll need to make a disclaimer that the flight stand is not included with her. For the price you're getting with her, she should at least come with that if we're not doing the mini poster thing this time. Yeah, we're back to not including the double sided mini poster like we did with only the Nolanverse Joker & Bane wave that had SuperReeve. Sure, the Returns wave not the Gunn Superslop movie didn't have mini posters, but at least he consistent with including or excluding them rather than make them a one off thing, Todd!
Some of her alternate hands include a right hand either suitable for karate or saluting as well as a left pointing hand, though she also comes with accessory holding hands presumably to showcase how her alternate head looks when shaved completely bald. Seriously, at least replace these hands with another head for a neutral expression. Also, the hands have blue paint to better go with the sleeves on the costume design.
One issue that arises with this figure is the hair doesn't really go in all the way whenever you switch between heads as this picture kind of shows, so you need to make sure that the head is not attached into the body yet. That way, it's easier to attach the piece onto her. The heat vision eyes are decently conveyed on this face, though I can't help but find it funny she looks like she's in the middle of an exorcism. Oh and she also has fists. While she turned out better than I was initially expecting, I still question why she was made a Theatrical Deluxe; maybe it's to have that synergy with the barley marketed Supergirl movie that'll probably come and go, but the accessory count is lesser than the Christopher Reeve Superman figure. Both versions, in fact. I'm not sure if you can get her for sale, but if the CW stuff isn't as popular as it once was, maybe it's possible to do just that. In the meantime, I will look for the titular Green Arrow of the same universe and Grant Gustin Flash.
As for Superman Returns, this figure is logically a retool of the Reeve body. Given Returns was supposed to be connected to the old quadrilogy (or at least the first two movies), why not go this route? New to.the sculpt are a head sculpt that looks better in hand than initial photos made it appear, a chest logo that is slightly larger than it was on the film suit, a set of trunks with the accurate logo on the belt (which is not from the Page Punchers version based on Lee Bermejo's art), and a pair of boots with texturing applied...that the rest of the suit could really use given that's how it appeared in the movie. Even the old action figures had that texturing, or at least most of them did. Not only that, but ignoring the flight stand (once again), what you see is what you get. Despite being a reuse of the Reeve body, we have no alternate hands for him, nor do the ones that come with Reeve even color match the skin tone on this figure. Worst of all, his cape has no bendy wire implemented! And it doesn't help that the Heat Vision BVS Superman retains his! What's going on with the selective choices between Todd and pals?!
Here he is along with Reeve and Cavill Supermen for an idea of what the Holy Trinity of actors who played the character was, is, and always will and should be. While I would love to have George Reeves to go with Adam West or maybe either Nicolas Cage for a deep lore cut (probably not so deep anymore given The Flush exists) and maybe Tyler Hoelchin so CW Supergirl won't be alone, this is a good selection of iterations to have on my display. Still, I can't help but feel bad that even in figure form, Routh gets the short end of the stick compared to Reeve and Cavill, especially with the wired cape situation.
Here he is with Christian Bale Batman in the Begins suit so we can get a bit of a "what could have been" in regards to a World's Finest match up if the DCEU castings didn't happen. I chose the Begins suit because it's closer to a comic aesthetic while retaining some realism and because it's the one Baleman from McFarlane I still have. Apparently, a Kingdom Come version of Routh is possible as a Platinum, but that should have been a thing to go alongside the regular Returns one. Also, even though I am happy to own A version of SuperRouth, I always say there is more room for improvement; the retooling could have gone further than it currently is, and even though he isn't a Deluxe Theatrical release, why can't he have alternate hands or a flight stand? And how many times am I going to bring up the cape. I would only recommend him if you're super into the movie, because while I have a soft spot for Returns and will easily prefer it over the 2025 scream fest from Gunn, I still find it out of place compared to other CBMs from the 2000s. While just about every title had either a present-day setting or was set in a specific time period for plot reasons, Superman Returns was said to take place 5 years after the second Reeve movie yet there is a jump in technology released during 2006. And most damning was that while the average 2000s CBM had the perfect balance of action, story, and kept things modern for new audiences being introduced to these characters, SR ends up feeling dour in aesthetics, was quieter for most of the movie, and was a mix between a vague hint of nostalgia and an awkward story of romance given Supes basically left Lois behind after a memory wipe...and pregnant no less while her husband had no idea of his superpowers. Maybe it holds up better in retrospect, but it's not a movie I would revisit immediately. And while many point out the pedophilic tweets Gunn made or some of the actions implied to paint him in that light prior to 2014 (not to mention associating himself with some sick freaks and poorly disassociating himself from them), we don't know if he's actually diddled kids the same way director Bryan Singer and Lex Luthor actor Kevin Spacey...but back on topic with the review, I can only recommend SuperRouth if you're a completionist or a diehard fan of the actor's portrayal. Now to see how he'll look on the Kingdom Come body.
Final ranking: ⭐⭐⭐ and a half out of ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (CW Supergirl)
⭐⭐ and a half out of ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (Superman Returns)























































