Here we have the Rebel Trooper in hand and helmetless. Surprised to say that he isn't a retool of Han Solo, even though he looks like he could have been one given Hasbro's tendency to reuse sculpts. The outfit at least is accurate to the movie, with the budget for A New Hope being smaller than the other movies. Still, the belt+holster, vest, and shiny boots are decently convincing for troops that are not in the same tier as Stormtroopers. Though the arm articulation is consistent with Black Series figures today, the knees are double jointed and have pins in them. The original Rebel Trooper run was part of a 2018 wave of figures.
His head sculpt is meant to look like one of the more prominent Rebel Troopers at the beginning of the movie, though their names are unidentified. For how similar he looks to Harrison Ford, I'm calling this dude Hamilton Fred. Articulation consists of standard neck movement, shoulder rotation, outward arm movement, rotation and bend at the elbows, wrist rotation and hinges, butterfly joints, a diaphragm joint, ball jointed hips, thigh rotation, double jointed knees, and ankles that hinge and pivot. In addition to his blaster, he comes with the Death Star plans, specifically the ones shaped more like how they appeared in Rogue One. I don't know how different the prop is between the one in ANH and the one in R1, but that's nothing to worry about compared to how much the ending of that movie doesn't line up with the Rebel Blockade Runner scene the more you think about it. But hey, it has callbacks to the Original Trilogy and that's all that matters.
As for the Stormtrooper, the only other version I have is the one used for a commemorative George Lucas version. While the sculpts or tooling may be the same, the biggest difference has to be the helmet on the non-George Stormtrooper not being removable. Makes sense since we never see Stormtroopers take their helmets off apart from the disguises Luke and Han wore in the Death Star.
Overall, this set is fine if you want to spend a specific amount of money on some troops without needing to find a certain variant in the aftermarket. Even though the Stormtroopers are done repeatedly, the Rebel Trooper, however uneventful he may look, at least adds a sense of completion to your OT display. I have this before the Phase 1 Clone vs Super Battle Droid but after the Phase 2 Clone vs B1 Battle Droid, so expect me to only get the sets from George's 6 movies lol.
Final ranking: ⭐⭐⭐ and a half out of ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐